=======  ============================================
SEP      1
Title    API for populating item fields (comparison)
Author   Ismael Carnales, Pablo Hoffman, Daniel Grana
Created  2009-07-19
Status   Obsoleted by :ref:`sep-008`
=======  ============================================

=====================================================
SEP-001 - API for populating item fields (comparison)
=====================================================

This page shows different usage scenarios for the two new proposed API for
populating item field values (which will replace the old deprecated !RobustItem
API)  and compares them. One of these will be chosen as the recommended (and
supported) mechanism in Scrapy 0.7.

Candidates and their API
========================

RobustItem (old, deprecated)
----------------------------

- ``attribute(field_name, selector_or_value, **modifiers_and_adaptor_args)``

.. note:: ``attribute()`` modifiers (like ``add=True``) are passed together
          with adaptor args as keyword arguments (this is ugly)

ItemForm
--------

- ``__init__(response, item=None, **adaptor_args)``
   - instantiate an ``ItemForm`` with a item instance with predefined adaptor arguments
- ``__setitem__(field_name, selector_or_value)``
   - set field value
- ``__getitem__(field_name)``
   - return the "computed" value of a field (the one that would be set to the item).
     returns ``None`` if not set.
- ``get_item()``
  - return the item populated with the data provided so far

ItemBuilder
-----------

- ``__init__(response, item=None, **adaptor_args)``
   - instantiate an ``ItemBuilder`` with predefined adaptor arguments
- ``add_value(field_name, selector_or_value, **adaptor_args)``
   - add value to field
- ``replace_value(field_name, selector_or_value, **adaptor_args)``
   - replace existing field value
- ``get_value(field_name)``
   - return the "computed" value of a field (the one that would be set to the
     item). returns ``None`` if not set.
- ``get_item()``
   - return the item populated with the data provided so far

Pros and cons of each candidate
===============================

ItemForm
--------

Pros:
- same API used for Items (see http://doc.scrapy.org/en/latest/topics/items.html)
- some people consider setitem API more elegant than methods API

Cons:
- doesn't allow passing run-time arguments to adaptors on assign, you have to
  override the adaptors for your spider if you need specific parameters, which
  can be an overhead. Example:

Neutral:
- solves the add=True problem using standard ``__add__`` and ``list.append()`` method

ItemBuilder
-----------

Pros:
- allows passing run-time arguments to adaptors on assigned

Cons:
- some people consider setitem API more elegant than methods API

Neutral:
- solves the "add=True" problem by implementing different methods per action
  (replacing or adding)

Usage Scenarios for each candidate
==================================

Defining adaptors
-----------------

ItemForm
~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   class NewsForm(ItemForm):
       item_class = NewsItem

       url = adaptor(extract, remove_tags(), unquote(), strip)
       headline = adaptor(extract, remove_tags(), unquote(), strip)

ItemBuilder
~~~~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   class NewsBuilder(ItemBuilder):
       item_class = NewsItem

       url = adaptor(extract, remove_tags(), unquote(), strip)
       headline = adaptor(extract, remove_tags(), unquote(), strip)

Creating an Item
----------------

ItemForm
~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   ia = NewsForm(response)
   ia['url'] = response.url
   ia['headline'] = x.x('//h1[@class="headline"]')

   # if we want to add another value to the same field
   ia['headline'] += x.x('//h1[@class="headline2"]')

   # if we want to replace the field value other value to the same field
   ia['headline'] = x.x('//h1[@class="headline3"]')

   return ia.get_item()

ItemBuilder
~~~~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   il = NewsBuilder(response)
   il.add_value('url', response.url)
   il.add_value('headline', x.x('//h1[@class="headline"]'))

   # if we want to add another value to the same field
   il.add_value('headline', x.x('//h1[@class="headline2"]'))

   # if we want to replace the field value other value to the same field
   il.replace_value('headline', x.x('//h1[@class="headline3"]'))

   return il.get_item()

Using different adaptors per Spider/Site
----------------------------------------

ItemForm
~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   class SiteNewsFrom(NewsForm):
       published = adaptor(HtmlNewsForm.published, to_date('%d.%m.%Y'))

ItemBuilder
~~~~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   class SiteNewsBuilder(NewsBuilder):
       published = adaptor(HtmlNewsBuilder.published, to_date('%d.%m.%Y'))

Check the value of an item being-extracted
------------------------------------------

ItemForm
~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   ia = NewsForm(response)
   ia['headline'] = x.x('//h1[@class="headline"]')
   if not ia['headline']:
       ia['headline'] = x.x('//h1[@class="title"]')

ItemBuilder
~~~~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   il = NewsBuilder(response)
   il.add_value('headline', x.x('//h1[@class="headline"]'))
   if not nf.get_value('headline'):
       il.add_value('headline', x.x('//h1[@class="title"]'))

Adding a value to a list attribute/field
----------------------------------------

ItemForm
~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   ia['headline'] += x.x('//h1[@class="headline"]')

ItemBuilder
~~~~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   il.add_value('headline', x.x('//h1[@class="headline"]'))

Passing run-time arguments to adaptors
--------------------------------------

ItemForm
~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   # Only approach is passing arguments when instantiating the form
   ia = NewsForm(response, default_unit='cm')
   ia['width'] = x.x('//p[@class="width"]')

ItemBuilder
~~~~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   il.add_value('width', x.x('//p[@class="width"]'), default_unit='cm')

   # an alternative approach (more efficient)
   il = NewsBuilder(response, default_unit='cm')
   il.add_value('width', x.x('//p[@class="width"]'))

Passing run-time arguments to adaptors (same argument name)
-----------------------------------------------------------

ItemForm
~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   class MySiteForm(ItemForm):
       witdth = adaptor(ItemForm.witdh, default_unit='cm')
       volume = adaptor(ItemForm.witdh, default_unit='lt')

   ia['width'] = x.x('//p[@class="width"]')
   ia['volume'] = x.x('//p[@class="volume"]')

   # another example passing parametes on instance
   ia = NewsForm(response, encoding='utf-8')
   ia['name'] = x.x('//p[@class="name"]')

ItemBuilder
~~~~~~~~~~~

::

   #!python
   il.add_value('width', x.x('//p[@class="width"]'), default_unit='cm')
   il.add_value('volume', x.x('//p[@class="volume"]'), default_unit='lt')
